
Vance's argument reflects a broader movement among those who identify as "heritage Americans," advocating for a vision of the United States primarily populated and governed by English-speaking Protestants and assimilated Catholics of Anglo-Saxon descent. Fea draws parallels between this contemporary rhetoric and historical nativist sentiments that surfaced during periods of significant demographic change in the U.S., such as the anti-Irish Catholic sentiments of the mid-19th century and the exclusionary attitudes towards Italians, Eastern Europeans, and Jews in the late 1800s. He also connects Vance's views to the Confederate ideology during the Civil War, which framed the conflict as an attack on Southern "heritage."
While Fea acknowledges that celebrating one's ethnic heritage can be positive, he warns against the dangers of a heritage-centric worldview. He argues that such a perspective can lead to tribalism and self-interest, undermining the sense of national community and civic virtue essential for a diverse democratic republic. This selective understanding of heritage tends to emphasize certain narratives while ignoring others, potentially fostering division rather than unity.
Fea cites historian David Lowenthal, who notes that heritage often "domesticates the past" to serve present-day agendas. This selective interpretation can distort historical realities and promote a narrow vision of American identity that excludes many groups. Ultimately, Fea advocates for a more inclusive understanding of citizenship that embraces the diverse tapestry of American identities rather than one based on heritage alone.
In conclusion, Fea's analysis invites readers to reflect critically on the implications of the "heritage America" narrative and urges a reconsideration of what it means to be part of a pluralistic society. He suggests that a healthy civic identity should transcend tribal affiliations and celebrate the rich diversity that characterizes the nation, promoting a sense of belonging and shared responsibility among all citizens.